Archive for category Multifamily Properties
Portland Apartment Market Well Into Recovery Period
Posted by Tom Smith in Multifamily Properties on August 13, 2011

The Portland metro’s supply/demand balance has shifted in favor of apartment owners, and with this year’s construction pipeline staying extremely light, rents are poised for solid growth through 2011. Re-employed residents steadily entered the rental market during the first half of the year, sending the market’s vacancy rate below 4 percent, a decade low, enabling operators to push up effective rents near pre-recession highs.
Since the start of 2011, operations in or near major employment centers in downtown Portland have posted the most significant increases to occupied stock. Apartment demand accelerated more than 3 percent during that time, and as further job creation enables additional renters to return to the market, the area’s vacancy rate will realign with long-term averages by year end. Employment growth also has translated into resurgent apartment demand in suburban communities, but the pace of rent growth farther from downtown is tiered.
A stronger upswing in rent gains for Class B/C properties remains several months away, but as the market’s lull in new supply magnifies absorption trends, lower-tier property owners will increasingly raise rents toward the close of 2011 as leases roll over.
With Portland’s rental market firmly rooted in recovery, deal flow has gained considerable momentum, particularly within the top tier. Over the past 12 months, transactions involving assets with more than 200 units doubled, pushing up the per-unit price for these properties by 20 percent. As a result, cap rates for larger deals have compressed to below 6 percent.
As the year progresses, some California buyers seeking higher yields than in their native markets will target Portland assets, bolstering Class A trading through year-end 2011. Given this heightened level of competition for top-tier inventory, buyers’ interest will progressively spread to a broader array of investment opportunities in both asset class and location, lifting deal flow across the board.
In general, average cap rates will start in the high-6 percent range for Class B properties in desirable locations and range to the high-7 percent range for lesser complexes or suburban areas.
2011 Annual Apartment Forecast
![]() |
Employment: Portland payrolls will expand by 29,000 workers in 2011, a 3 percent gain, outpacing the addition of 4,600 jobs last year. The creation of 5,900 typically higher-paying professional and business services positions bodes well for downtown apartment owners, as a sizable share of these residents are likely to seek housing near work. |
![]() |
Construction: Developers will complete 96 units in 2011, a mere 0.1 percent rise in existing stock, all of which will come online in the Inner North/Northeast/Southeast submarket. Supply growth in 2011 will remain 92 percent below the five-year annual average. Last year, 660 units were delivered to the metro. |
![]() |
Vacancy: Slower construction activity and recovering demand will drive down vacancy again this year. During 2011, vacancy will slide 140 basis points to 3.1 percent, after retracting 240 basis points last year. |
![]() |
Rents: Asking rents will rise 4 percent to $853 per month in 2011, as effective rents inflate 4.8 percent to $781 per month, reducing average concessions offered by three days of free rent. In 2010, apartment operators in the Portland metro raised asking and effective rents by 2.1 percent and 2.8 percent, respectively. |
Economy
- In the first half of 2011, local employers added 15,600 jobs, a solid 1.6 percent increase, outpacing the addition of 8,100 positions during the same period one year earlier.
- Employment growth has been led by the trade, transportation and utilities sectors since the start of this year, which grew by 5,500 workers, a turnaround from the loss of 1,200 jobs in the prior two quarters. The only two sectors to shed jobs thus far in 2011 have been leisure and hospitality and other services segments, shrinking by a total of 1,700 spots.
- With the national economy on better footing, several metro employers have announced plans to expand staffing levels to meet growing demand. StairMaster and Sapa Group, for instance, have released plans to hire 100 workers each this year in Vancouver.
- Outlook: Portland employment levels will expand by 29,000 workers in 2011, a 3 percent gain, outpacing the addition of 4,600 jobs last year.
Housing And Demographics
- Single-family permit issuance increased 3 percent year over year in the sector quarter to 3,650 units, though housing starts fell by 7 percent. The number of multifamily permits pulled jumped 29 percent over the past 12 months to 1,230 units, which is still 80 percent below 2006 levels.
- In the second quarter, the median home price was $229,000, a year-over-year decrease of 3.6 percent. The median household income of $57,660 per year is $4,300 higher than the minimum qualifying income for a median-priced home.
- Using conventional financing terms, the monthly mortgage obligation for a median-priced metro home was $240 per month less than the average Class A asking rent as of the second quarter.
- Outlook: The pace of household formation will strengthen in the year ahead as the Portland metro enters a more vigorous recovery, resulting in the projected addition of 20,000 new households by year-end 2011, supporting healthy demand for housing.
Construction
- In the 12 months ending in the second quarter, developers completed 580 rental units, expanding existing inventory a modest 0.6 percent. One year earlier, more than 1,500 units were brought online.
- Thus far in 2011, two developments totaling 70 units were put into service in the Inner North/Northeast/Southeast submarket, increasing area stock by 1 percent.
- As of the second quarter, the market’s construction pipeline remained thin, with fewer than 180 units under construction. The number of planned projects total 2,980 units, but only 350 of those units contained established ground breaking dates.
- Outlook: Developers will complete 96 units in 2011, all of which will come online in the Inner North/Northeast/Southeast submarket. Last year, 660 units were delivered to the metro.
Vacancy
- Solid job growth, combined with slowing completions drove down the vacancy rate 100 basis points through the first half of 2011 to 3.5 percent. Measured year over year, the Portland metro registered a solid 220 basis point improvement, after falling 50 basis points in the preceding 12 months.
- Both Class A and Class B/C properties are benefiting from resurgent employment gains. In the past year, top-tier buildings posted a 230 basis point decrease in vacancy to 3.8 percent, while lower-tier apartments recorded a 220 basis point fall to an extremely tight 3.2 percent in the second quarter.
- As re-employed residents relocated closer to major employment centers, operational improvements in the Northwest/Downtown submarket have outpaced the market as a whole. During the past 12 months, the area registered a 310 basis point vacancy decrease to 7 percent, which is 730 basis points below the cyclical high reached in the third quarter of 2009.
- Outlook: Slower construction activity and recovering demand will drive down vacancy again this year. During 2011, vacancy will slide 140 basis points to 3.1 percent, after retracting 240 basis points last year.
Rents
- Over the 12 months ending in the second quarter, asking rents climbed 3.1 percent to $830 per month, and effective rents rose 3.6 percent to $757 month. During the first two quarters, asking and effective rents increased 1.2 percent and 1.6 percent, respectively.
- Asking rents in the Class A sector advanced 3.4 percent over the past 12 months to $965 per month in the first quarter, while the lower tier posted a 2.5 percent gain in that time to $706 per month.
- As occupied stock climbed and owners resumed raising rents, Portland apartment owners registered revenue growth of 6 percent over the past year, compared with a 0.3 percent decrease one year earlier.
- Outlook: Asking rents will rise 4 percent to $853 per month in 2011, as effective rents inflate 4.8 percent to $781 per month, reducing average concessions offered by three days of free rent.
Sales Trends**
- Transaction velocity increased nearly 13 percent during most recent trailing 12-month period, a considerable improvement when compared with a 31 percent drop in the preceding year.
- An enlarging pool of active investors has driven up the market’s price 10 percent over the past year to $69,700 per unit. The per-unit price for institution grade assets rose 21 percent year over year to $84,700.
- In the past 12 months, average cap rates fell 40 basis points to the mid-to high-6-percent range. Initial yields for institutional-grade properties, however, have averaged closer to the low-6 percent range, with a handful changing hands in the mid-5 percent neighborhood.
- Outlook: With the supply pipeline to stay empty and an influx of buyers reentering the market, the gap between buyers’ and sellers’ expectations that existed in recent years is quickly dissipating. This year, buyers in search of performing, well-maintained assets will be required to stretch for listings.
Capital Markets
By William E. Hughes, Senior Vice President, Marcus & Millichap Capital Corporation
- Apartment mortgage rates should remain favorable through 2011, enhancing property returns and supporting values. While the 10-year Treasury yield likely will remain in the low-to mid-3 percent range over the next few quarters, the relatively wide spread to all-in lending rates provides some cushion against potential upticks.
- Encouraged by sustained improvements in occupancy and rents, nearly all lending sources have increased funding for apartment deals. As a result, mortgage debt has become readily available for performing assets across markets and property classes, supporting a 40 percent increase in multi-family origination volume over the past six months when compared to the previous period.
- The agencies continue to dominate but have lost marketshare as insurance companies, private capital sources and local/regional banks, in particular, compete more aggressively for new business. In the near term, life insurance companies will continue to favor larger, best-of-class assets in primary markets, while local and regional banks focus on lower-quality assets with consistent revenue streams and strong, proven sponsorship.
- Underwriting requirements eased over the past year as strengthening apartment fundamentals and firming property values restored lenders’ confidence in the market. Debt-service coverage requirements slipped to 1.15 to 1.25, while loan-to-values on new loans generally improved to 70 to 75 percent, and in some limited situations, have pushed to as high as 80 percent.
Submarket Overview
- In the second quarter, Class A vacancy in downtown Portand settled at 8.4 percent, down from 21.5 percent recorded late in 2009. Since the start of 2011, the area’s top-tier vacancy rate has fallen 460 basis points, supporting a 2.3 percent year-to-date jump in asking rents.
- Investors will stay keen on assets in the Beaverton/Aloha submarket, which stands to benefit from Intel’s plans to develop facilities in Hillsboro. The project will create thousands of construction jobs this year and hundreds of permanent white-collar positions when completed in 2013.
- Several other major companies, including Nike, Boeing and IBM, also announced plans to increase hiring efforts this year, which will strengthen demand for housing in both Beaverton and Gresham going forward.
Submarket Vacancy Ranking

** Data reflects a full 12-month period, calculated on a trailing 12-month basis by quarter.
The information contained in this report was obtained from sources deemed to be reliable. Every effort was made to obtain accurate and complete information; however, no representation, warranty or guarantee, express or implied, may be made as to the accuracy or reliability of the information contained herein. Note: Metro-level employment growth is calculated using seasonally adjusted quarterly averages. Sales data includes transactions valued at $500,000 and greater unless otherwise noted. Sources: Marcus & Millichap Research Services, Bureau of Labor Statistics, CoStar Group, Inc., Economy.com, National Association of Realtors, Real Capital Analytics, Reis, TWR/Dodge Pipeline, U.S. Census Bureau.
Portland, Oregon Metro Area Q4 Apartment Research Market Update
Posted by Tom Smith in Main, Multifamily Properties on January 17, 2011
HEALTHY OUTLOOK, LOW INTEREST RATES SPUR BIDDING ACTIVITY
Below-trend completions helped balance apartment supply and demand in the Portland metro, despite a slow-moving job recovery. With private-sector employers no longer shedding jobs, the local economic outlook has improved, giving households who doubled up during the recession the confidence to lease individual apartments.
Existing complexes will continue to field these returning renters, as building activity remains low. As a result, vacancies will improve further through year end, and absorption levels, which turned positive in each submarket this year, will continue to strengthen.
Locations near downtown currently account for the bulk of leasing activity, a trend expected to intensify in 2011 as employers ramp up hiring. Luxury condos recast as rentals may present some top-tier supply exposure in the city, but the overall impact of such stock will be minimal, as the bulk of this supply has been absorbed through steep rental discounts.
As rehired professionals rent more affordable mid-tier units, downtown rent rolls will show stronger improvements next year, pulling the vacancy rate in the Northwest/Downtown submarket closer to historical averages. Challenges will persist, nonetheless, as leasing in outlying blue-collar areas will remain light until broader job growth occurs in mid-2011.
As recovering property operations boost buyer confidence and interest rates remain low, investment activity will increase. With interest rates low and buyers recognizing a wave of REO listings will not likely materialize, more investors are making offers on well-located assets.
Properties near downtown Portland continue to capture the most attention, with cap rates for best-in-class assets averaging in the low-6 percent range. Prolonged marketing times in 2009 and early this year encouraged sellers marketwide to lower price points to divest ahead of possible capital tax gains increases, though price cuts were largely mild. Owners of complexes farther from downtown amenities, particularly where renter turnover is most pronounced, have decreased prices sharply to compete with the greater availability of listings; initial yields for these assets currently average between 7.5 percent and 8.0 percent.
2010 ANNUAL APARTMENT FORECAST
![]() |
Employment: Resumed private-sector hiring in the fourth quarter will expand marketwide employment by 2,000 positions this year, a 0.2 percent increase. In 2009, Portland staffing levels fell by 55,000 workers. After cutting jobs for two consecutive years, white-collar employers will account for a sizable share of gains in 2010, a trend that bodes well for renter demand downtown. |
![]() |
Construction: Development activity will fall below historical norms this year, with builders on track to complete just 660 units, down from 2,034 units in 2009 and the smallest num- ber of apartments brought online since 2005. Over the past five years, deliveries averaged 1,200 units annually. |
![]() |
Vacancy: The average vacancy rate will finish the year at 4.8 percent, representing a 210 basis point improvement from 2009, when weaker economic conditions caused vacancy to rise 170 basis points. |
![]() |
Rents: During 2010, asking rents will increase 1.9 percent to $818 per month, and effective rents will rise 2.5 percent to $743 per month. Last year, asking rents slipped 2.7 percent, while effective rents dropped 5.1 percent. |
- The local job market recovery remains in flux, as the elimination of tem- porary census workers during the third quarter offset employment gains achieved in the first half. Year over year, Portland employers shed 8,500 positions for a 0.9 percent head count decrease, following the loss of 75,800 workers in the preceding 12-month period. Excluding government payroll reductions, metrowide employment levels flattened year to date.
- The government, financial activities and construction sectors lost a total of 4,600 jobs over the past year, outpacing gains recorded in the professional and business services and education and health services segments.
- Nike Inc. leased more than 190,000 square feet of space in two buildings in Beaverton. The company expects to hire 160 permanent positions to oc- cupy the new facilities. In addition, Intel Corp. plans to build a new plant in Hillsboro, which will create up to 1,000 permanent jobs and 6,000 to 8,000 constructions positions. The project is slated for delivery in 18 months.
- Outlook: Marketwide employment levels will expand by 2,000 positions this year, a 0.2 percent increase and a considerable improvement from 2009, when 55,000 workers were eliminated.
- Over the past year, permits for 3,600 single-family housing units were is- sued, up from 2,780 units during the previous 12 months. Multifamily per- mit issuance fell 3 percent annually to 970 units.
- The median home price dipped 2 percent year over year to $236,500. Household income levels remained flat during that time at $55,900 per year, $1,400 less than the minimum required to qualify for purchasing a median-priced home.
- Renting will remain the most affordable option for most residents. Current- ly, the average Class A asking rent is $285 per month less than the typical mortgage obligation on a median-priced home, using conventional financ- ing criteria.
- Outlook: Along with the disparity between the monthly rent and mortgage payment, stricter lending criteria and a high unemployment rate will deter a sizable share of residents from leaping into ownership in the near term.
CONSTRUCTION

- Approximately 650 apartment units came online in the Portland metro over the past year, down considerably from the completion of 2,287 units in the prior 12-month stretch.
- The only complex delivered so far in 2010 was the 152-unit Broadstone Enso in the Northwest/Downtown submarket, added during the first quarter.
- All 550 apartment units under way in the metro will come online in the Northwest/Downtown submarket during the fourth quarter. The planning pipeline consists of 1,600 units, only 7 percent of which have established start dates.
- Outlook: Developers will complete 660 units this year, down from 2,034 units in 2009. Over the past five years, deliveries averaged 1,200 units annually.
VACANCY

- Since reaching a cyclical peak in the third quarter of last year, marketwide vacancy has fallen 210 basis points to 4.8 percent, supported by strong de- mand for Class A rentals.
- Top-tier vacancy averaged 4.9 percent in the third quarter, down 290 basis points from the same period last year. Operators of Class A complexes in the Northwest/Downtown submarket, where developments efforts were concentrated in recent years, posted the largest vacancy reduction over the past year, driven by generous concessions offered to fill newer units.
- In the Class B/C segment, vacancy improved 140 basis points year over year to 4.7 percent, a rate below the sector’s five-year average.
- Outlook: Vacancy will finish the year at 4.8 percent, down 210 basis points from 2009, when weaker economic conditions caused vacancy to rise 170 basis points.
RENTS

- Recent occupancy gains have allowed owners to raise rents. Thus far in 2010, asking rents have advanced 1 percent to $811 per month, and effective rents have risen 1.7 percent to $737 per month.
- Class A asking rents reached $940 per month in the third quarter, up 2.3 percent from one year earlier and nearly on par with the peak levels at- tained during the third quarter of 2008. Lower-tier asking rents advanced 1.6 percent year over year to $693 per month but remain 4 percent less than the sector’s cyclical high.
- Operational improvements have encouraged many owners to scale back in- centives. In the third quarter, concessions totaled 33 days of free rent, down three days from the start of 2010. Average revenues, meanwhile, have risen 3.9 percent so far this year.
- Outlook: Asking rents will increase 1.9 percent to $818 per month, and ef- fective rents will rise 2.5 percent to $743 per month.
SALES TRENDS**

- Investment activity in Portland has yet to recover, though the slowdown has eased considerably, with sales velocity dipping just 10 percent over the most recent 12-month stretch. In the prior year, deal flow fell 47 percent.
- Subdued trading has led to a 9 percent decrease in the median price over the past year to $63,300 per unit. During the last six months, assets sold at a median price of $65,600 per unit.
- Cap rates increased approximately 50 basis points in the past year to the high-6 percent to low-7 percent range, though lower-tier assets traded with initial yields closer to 8 percent.
- Outlook: Lower-tier listing availability remains greatest in the east, where Class C assets with deferred maintenance currently list at cap rates begin- ning in the low-8 percent range. The Gresham area, in particular, fared well through the downturn due to its affordability but weakened considerably late in the recession as residents took in roommates. With hiring yet to gain momentum, local residents in the area will remain slow to de-bundle.
CAPITAL MARKETS
- The yield on the 10-year U.S. Treasury held in the mid-2 percent range through October due to concerns regarding the durability of economic re- covery. The yield last peaked at 4 percent in early April of this year.
- Despite significant losses and ongoing troubles associated with Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac’s residential mortgage portfolios, their multifamily hold- ings continue to outperform, with delinquency rates holding well below 1 percent. The GSEs and commercial banks remain the dominant sources of financing for apartments, but life insurance companies have begun to com- pete more intensely for attractive deals that meet their criteria.
- Loan-to-values (LTVs) among portfolio lenders range from 55 percent to 75 percent depending on asset quality and location, as well the strength of the borrower. For best-of-class deals financed by agency lenders, LTVs can push closer to 80 percent. Lenders generally require debt-service coverage ratios of 1.25x to 1.30x, well above pre-crisis levels but relatively close to historical norms.
- All-in mortgage rates offered by portfolio lenders on smaller seven-year loans range from 4.80 percent to 5.75 percent, while agency loans typically price 55 basis points to 100 basis points lower, depending on the deal. Larger seven-year loans of $5 million or more price between 4.5 percent and 5.5 per- cent among portfolio lenders and 4.0 percent to 4.5 percent for the agencies.
SUBMARKET OVERVIEW
- Since peaking at 21.5 percent last year, the Class A vacancy rate in the Northwest/Downtown submarket has improved to 12 percent, despite supply additions during the first quarter. Late-2011 completions will inflate vacancy modestly, but the rise will be temporary, and resumed job growth will continue to drive up occupancies in the area.
- Vancouver received a $3 million grant to redevelop the Crescent industrial area. The gentrification effort could generate up to 750 jobs, boosting the city’s work force and bolstering rental absorption.
- Vestas Wind Systems will lease space in the Pearl District and transform the old Meier & Frank Warehouse into a 172,000-square foot headquarters. The move will create up to 200 permanent positions in the next few years, as well as 450 construction jobs, bolstering demand for local housing.
SUBMARKET VACANCY RANKING

Investors Eye Apartments and Distressed Properties
Posted by Tom Smith in Multifamily Properties on January 16, 2011
This is a very encouraging report from RetailTraffic…
Apartments remain the favored property type among risk-averse investors. Nearly half of respondents (46%) to a quarterly survey conducted by National Real Estate Investor, Retail Traffic and Marcus & Millichap Real Estate Investment Services indicate that now is the time to buy apartments, up from 38% in the second quarter.
Demand for apartments is even stronger among respondents who are already invested in that particular property type with 61% of apartment investors saying now is the time to buy more multifamily product.
Investors are less confident in other sectors expressing the most interest in buying undeveloped land (28%), followed by retail (26%), and industrial (24%). Respondents were most bearish on hotels with only 18% indicating now is the time to buy Figure 3.
Apartments have not escaped the current downturn unscathed. The sector reported its weakest net absorption totals for the second quarter in more than a decade with just 900 units absorbed, according to real estate research firm Reis based in New York.
The national vacancy rate also rose to 7.6%, up 150 basis points over the same period a year ago. Yet the apartment sector may be a preferred choice simply because it has fared better than property types such as the office market, which reported a national vacancy rate of 15.9% in the second quarter.
Investors also appear more confident that effective rents for apartments will hold their own going forward, indicating the worst of rent adjustments is over. Nearly half of respondents (47%) believe rents will remain flat, 27% anticipate an increase and 23% predict a decline.
Those that do expect a dip in effective rents anticipate a 1% drop, which is well below expectations for other sectors such as office (5.2%), retail (5.1%), and mixed-use properties (5.1%).
Investors also are waiting for a wave of distressed properties to enter the market. In fact, 80% of respondents expect that volume of distressed properties to be moderate to large.
More than half of respondents (55%) believe distressed properties will be most widespread among retail malls, followed by hotels (53%), suburban office (48%), undeveloped land (42%), and retail lifestyle and power centers (40%).
Yet it could be early 2010 before a significant amount of distressed properties make it into the marketplace. The process required to re-price, re-tenant or write off those distressed assets is going to be complex.
“There’s a lot of emphasis on workouts by commercial banks who are not yet strong enough to withstand another round of large losses,” says Hessam Nadji, managing director at Marcus & Millichap. CMBS loans have an added layer of complexity due to the very nature of the securitized model.
“All of this points to a very different situation than the 1990s, when the Resolution Trust Corp. acted as a clearing house of distressed real estate,” Hessam adds. “Either way you look at it, I think you will see that turning point occur in the next six to 12 months.”
Would you like to know more about how multi-family and distressed properties could benefit your investment strategy? Contact me for a free consultation.
Investors Snap Up High-Quality Multifamily Properties as Rents, Occupancy Improve
Posted by Tom Smith in Multifamily Properties on August 31, 2010
This is a very interesting piece from Randyl Drummer over at the CoStar Group…
Competition Fierce for Choice Assets But Deals Aren’t As Prolific in the First Half of Year as Some Analysts Expected
With apartment vacancies appearing to have peaked, and US rents even starting to edge up slightly, offerings of quality multifamily assets have attracted multiple bidders and secured premium prices in the first half of 2010, with investors having an especially keen appetite for institutional-grade assets in attractive coastal markets.
However, as with most asset classes in the current commercial real estate market, multifamily sales are largely divided between the asset haves and have-nots. With few high-quality performing apartment assets for sale and an abundance of pent-up capital seeking to invest, some properties have drawn multiple, even dozens, of bids.
Recovery and transaction activity in the broader investment market for apartments and condominiums has not been nearly as swift or as strong as some experts predicted at the beginning of the year, despite modestly improving occupancies and rents, according to CoStar Group Real Estate Economist Mark Hickey.
Through the first six months of 2010, $11.6 billion in multifamily property traded hands, up from $7.7 billion in the first half of last year, according to preliminary 2010 CoStar first-half sales statistics. The first half total is expected to increase as CoStar continues to tabulate market transactions that closed in the second quarter. Despite a flurry that brought $19.9 billion in activity at the end of last year, the prorated dollar volume for all of 2010 still pencils out to $23.3 billion, or a 17% increase over 2009, Hickey said. Although this year’s projected volume would still be a 44% drop from the bubble-driven sales level in 2008 and a 74% drop from 2007, he said.
CoStar real estate economist Katie Pelczar memorably likened the scramble for the highest grade Class A assets seen on both coasts to old wartime photos where “hundreds of people are pushing and shoving to get their hands on a single loaf of pumpernickel.” Deals for those coveted morsels, in this case well-occupied and higher priced properties in core markets like Washington, DC or New York, have thus far accounted for much of the sales activity this year.
Buyers in general are assuming they’re going to see hefty rent increases and continued demand recovery due to the shutdown of the supply pipeline and the improving economy, said CoStar Global Strategist Michael B. Cohen.
“The flip side to that is people are looking at the velocity of transactions and beginning to feel like the market is getting a little frothy,” Cohen said. “We’re generally seeing cap rate compression in those high-quality assets in coastal markets that people are paying high prices for. The returns are not the type of opportunistic returns investors thought they would see a year ago. Instead of a heavy distress play, we’ve seen a heavy core play.”
Meanwhile, supply is tightening, home ownership remains soft and vacancies appear to have topped out, even declining in some markets. While asking rents are trending lat, the market is seeing some positive growth in effective rents as concessions burn off in such markets as Phoenix. Landlords are starting to feel the balance of power shift in their favor, Cohen said.
The appetite of investors for the prime markets, however, has largely driven the increase in dollar volume, while the number of trades has flattened. The weighted average price per unit, which was about $28,000 in the first half of 2009, is an estimated $40,400 in first-half 2010, according to available data.
REITs and other investors lush with equity are the most active players in the apartment sales arena, with financing challenges still playing out across the market.
“Gap financing continues to be an issue for buyers that need some amount of leverage before an asset stabilizes,” noted a participant in the second-quarter PricewaterhouseCoopers Korpacz Real Estate Investor Survey. The bid-ask gap has narrowed, mostly because sellers have acknowledged current market conditions. Betraying continued uncertainty, Korpacz survey participants offered mixed views on asset values, with some foreseeing increases of as much as 15% and others expecting continued declines of as much as 25%.
Investor interest isn’t relegated solely to Class A properties, and pockets of strength have turned up in some interesting markets, notably Phoenix, hard hit by the single-family housing crisis and shadow supply of homes and condominiums.
“There’s more of an investor appetite for Class A properties, but at the same time, you’ve seen more price declines and fundamentals declines on the lower properties. There’s a large number of groups that want distressed assets, B-minus and under,” said Jack Hannum, vice president with Transwestern. Hannum and Vice President Bret Zinn are co-leaders of Transwestern’s multifamily team in Phoenix. “There’s just a tremendous appetite for all multifamily product here. If a deal goes to market, there’s high demand for it.”
On the financing side, government-sponsored entities Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have long been the dominant providers of debt capital in multifamily, a trend expected to continue despite the political and market challenges the agencies face. However, one increasing trend since the beginning of the year is the growing participation of life insurance companies, noted Jeff Majewski, executive managing director, capital markets, for Grubb & Ellis. For most of 2008 and 2009, the insurers were out of that market and effectively ceded that business to the GSE agencies, but they’re back strongly this year.
“The life companies have come into the space and they are aggressively competing with the agencies — and in many instances winning many of the top-tier Class A projects — primarily because they’re willing to take on a little bit more lease-up risk,” Majewski said. “We think that’s going to continue through 2010. We don’t see any slowdown in their appetite for multifamily.”
Hannum and Zinn recently represented Weidner Investment Services, based in Kirkland, WA, in a $16.65 million off-market acquisition of the 258-unit Monterra apartment community in Phoenix from Aslan Realty Group, a deal which closed in under two months. Weidner said it plans to hold onto the property long term to take advantage of increasing net rental income and falling vacancies as the Phoenix market continues its expected recovery over the next 18 months.
Weidner “just flat-out told Jack and I they wanted to buy 3,000 units and wanted to be in Phoenix,” Zinn said.
With so much demand and lack of high-end product on the market, apartment buyers are willing to pay the so-called “scarcity premium” for quality assets, Zinn said. At the same time, many investors who raised funds two or three years ago but were forced to wait on the sidelines for the market to stabilize may now face deadlines to deploy that capital.
“We get calls daily from new groups that want to be in Phoenix and are ready to buy. We just don’t have enough product to show them,” Zinn said. “A year ago, no one in the market was convinced we were at the bottom. Over the last three to six months, there’s a lot more investor comfort in Phoenix that the market is at bottom and now is the time to buy.”
“Prices are where they were 10 years ago. In the C market, prices are where they were 15 to 20 years ago,” Hannum added. “Net effective rents aren’t going any lower. You’ve still got good sources of financing with Freddie and Fannie. A lot of these buyer groups aren’t concerned with timing the bottom perfectly; they’re going to cost-in their acquisitions and average in the bottom.”
Also in the Phoenix market, Colliers International recently negotiated the sale of two Class B apartment assets in Mesa, AZ, to San Mateo, CA based Acacia Capital for $33.35 million. The 304-unit Verona Park property sold for $15.2 million, or $50,000 per unit. Argenta, 395 units, sold for $18.15 million, or $45,949 per unit.
“We had a very strong response with multiple offers at, or over, list price,” said Brad Cooke, vice president with Colliers’ Phoenix of ice, who along with vice president Cindy Cooke, represented the undisclosed seller. “It came down to who had the funds to close all-cash on both properties, could move fast, and had an in depth knowledge of the two submarkets.”
REITs and institutions targeted large properties in major markets this year, but private equity players were also in the mix. A sampling of other significant multifamily transactions tracked by CoStar in the first two quarters includes the following:
- Equity Residential (NYSE: EQR), the largest apartment REIT, in the first quarter acquired three luxury apartment complexes in Manhattan from Macklowe Properties, River Tower, 777 Sixth Street, and the Longacre House, for more than 900 units in deals totaling $475 million.
- A private equity firm identified only as Standard Austin acquired multifamily portfolios totaling 5,000 units across 16 properties in Maryland and Texas from Irvine, CA-based Bethany Group out of Chapter 11 bankruptcy for a reported $327.7 million.
- Select Investment Realty Advisors, LLC on June 7 closed on the sale of the Fairhaven Multifamily Garden apartment portfolio in Long Island, NY, seven assets totaling 1,666 units located in Nassau and Suffolk counties. Eagle Rock Management, LLC acquired the portfolio for $229.75 million.
- Equity Residential acquired 425 Mass, a 559-unit condo/apartment property in Washington, DC for $167 million, in a bankruptcy deal.
- Watermarke Properties bought the Gardens at Wilshire Center mixed-use apartment project, a Class-A asset with 159 units between Beverly Hills and downtown Los Angeles, for $48 million. Watermarke was among 30 bidders for the asset.










